The Gifting Dilemma

We all know him. The man who’s impossible to buy for. He already has the watch, the golf clubs, the tailored suits, and the latest tech. Birthdays, anniversaries, Christmas, it’s the same headache every time. So what do you buy the man who has everything?

The answer isn’t more “stuff.” The answer is indulgence, sophistication, and experience, in other words, whisky and cigars. These aren’t just gifts; they’re timeless pleasures, steeped in ritual and rich in character. When chosen well, they cut through the noise of mass-produced, forgettable presents and deliver something truly memorable.

Why Whisky & Cigars Make the Perfect Gift

There’s a reason whisky and cigars have stood the test of time as the ultimate symbols of luxury. They’re more than consumables, they’re experiences.

• Timeless appeal: Both whisky and cigars have centuries of tradition behind them.
• Personal and thoughtful: Each bottle or cigar has its own story, terroir, and flavour profile.
• Sophisticated indulgence: Perfect for unwinding, celebrating, or marking a milestone.
• Memorable moments: A dram or cigar enjoyed by the fire at Christmas lingers in memory longer than gadgets or trinkets.

For the man who has everything, whisky and cigars offer something he doesn’t already own: an indulgence he can savour and enjoy.

Whisky Gifts for the Man Who Has Everything

When it comes to gifting whisky, think beyond the supermarket shelf. This is about choosing something with impact, presence, and, if possible, a touch of exclusivity.

1. Rare & Limited Edition Whiskies

One of the easiest ways to impress is with scarcity. Limited releases and rare bottlings are gifts that show thought and sophistication. These are whiskies that can’t be found everywhere, which means they feel like treasures.

• Examples: Single cask releases, distillery exclusives, or independent bottlings.
• Perfect for: Collectors or seasoned whisky lovers who enjoy something unique.

At Robert Graham 1874, our independent bottlings and small-batch releases tick this box beautifully. Each one is a limited piece of whisky history, bottled with care.

2. The Robert Graham 1874 Core Range

If you’re not sure what to buy, but want something reliable, smooth, and beautifully presented, the Robert Graham 1874 Core Range is a safe but stylish bet.

• Why it works: Accessible flavour profiles that appeal to a wide range of tastes.
• Packaging: Elegant and gift-ready.
• Versatility: Enjoy neat, on the rocks, or in festive cocktails.
• Lochwood Tower, Cearban, Hoebeg & Ailein Mor. 

These are whiskies you can confidently place under the tree knowing they’ll be well received.

3. Collector’s Bottles

For the man who enjoys prestige, go for well-known names and older age statements. They don’t just deliver a fine drink, they make a statement.

• Examples: Glenfiddich 18 Year Old, Macallan Rare Cask, or Lagavulin Distillers Edition.
• Why they impress: Recognisable, respected, and instantly luxurious.

These bottles are just as at home in a display cabinet as they are in a glass.

4. Whisky Gift Sets & Accessories

Sometimes the extras make all the difference. A bottle paired with branded glassware, a tasting kit, or even a decanter elevates the gift from “just whisky” to a full experience.

• Examples: Gift packs with miniatures, whisky tasting flights, or glass + bottle bundles.
• Why they work: They’re interactive and extend the experience beyond one dram.

5. Whisky Experiences

If he really does have every bottle, consider giving him the chance to explore more.

• Options:
  • Private tasting sessions
  • Whisky subscriptions
  • Tickets to a Robert Graham 1874 event

An experience means memories, not clutter, and that’s invaluable for the man who “has it all.”

Cigar Gifts for the Man Who Has Everything

Cigars are more than smoke, they’re ritual. Lighting one is a statement, an event in itself, and for the man who has everything, cigars are one of life’s ultimate indulgences.

1. Prestigious Cuban Cigars

Nothing says “luxury” like a fine Cuban. They’re recognisable, aspirational, and universally respected.

• Examples: Cohiba, Montecristo, Partagás.
• Why they impress: They carry instant prestige and are linked with celebration.

2. Limited Edition or Vintage Cigars

If you want exclusivity, look for rare or aged cigars. These are perfect for collectors or connoisseurs who value rarity.

• Examples: Limited annual releases or discontinued lines.
• Why they work: They feel like once-in-a-lifetime opportunities.

3. Cigar Sampler Boxes

Not sure which cigar he’ll love? Let him explore.

• Why they’re perfect: Variety in one gift box means he can try different strengths, flavours, and sizes.
• Bonus: They look stunning as a gift set.

4. Luxury Cigar Accessories

Sometimes, it’s the accessories that make the biggest impact.

• Options: Humidors, lighters, cutters, ashtrays.
• Why they impress: They’re functional and stylish, ideal for someone who loves the ritual.

5. Whisky & Cigar Pairings

For the ultimate indulgence, pair the two together. Imagine gifting a bottle of Robert Graham 1874 Core Range whisky with a handpicked Cuban cigar, two luxuries in harmony.

• Why it works: It creates a complete experience.
• Perfect for: A partner or relative who enjoys the finer things in life.

Experience Over Possession

Here’s the secret: the man who has everything doesn’t actually want “more things.” What he wants are moments.

A fine whisky enjoyed by the fire. A cigar shared with friends after Christmas dinner. The ritual, the pause, the indulgence, that’s what makes whisky and cigars the ultimate gifts.

When in Doubt: Gift Vouchers

Still unsure? Sometimes the man who has everything really does have everything. In that case, a Robert Graham 1874 gift voucher is the ultimate safety net. 

• Flexible and thoughtful
• Allows him to choose his own whisky or cigar
• Perfect for last-minute gifting

Buying for the man who has everything doesn’t have to be stressful. Forget gadgets, novelty socks, or last-minute Amazon panic. Instead, choose indulgence, sophistication, and timeless luxury.

From delicious single malts to prestigious Cuban cigars and indulgent pairings, whisky and cigars are gifts that make an impression. And if you’re really stuck? A gift voucher ensures the perfect dram or cigar is never far away.

For Christmas 2025, give him a gift that’s more than an object. Give him an experience. Give him whisky and cigars.